Email vs SMS Marketing: Which Drives Better Customer Retention?

Which is better for customer retention: email or SMS marketing? Here’s the short answer: SMS is faster and grabs attention with a 98% open rate, while email is cost-effective and excels at delivering detailed, personalized content. For the best results, use both together.

Key Insights:

• SMS Strengths: High engagement with a 45% response rate and instant delivery. Ideal for urgent updates and flash sales.

• Email Strengths: Cost-effective with an average ROI of $36 per $1 spent, great for in-depth communication and nurturing relationships.

• Quick Comparison:

Best Strategy: Combine both channels. Use SMS for immediate communication and email for detailed follow-ups. Together, they create a stronger retention strategy.

SMS vs. Email Marketing: Which One is Right for Your Business?

Performance Metrics: Email vs SMS

When comparing email and SMS marketing for customer retention, the differences in engagement and effectiveness are clear. Let’s dive into the performance metrics that matter most for retention success.

Message Open Rates

SMS has a clear edge over email when it comes to open and response rates. Why? Text messages are immediate and hard to miss on mobile devices. Emails, on the other hand, often get buried in cluttered inboxes. Most SMS messages are read within minutes, making them ideal for time-sensitive campaigns.

Customer Response and Sales

Here’s a breakdown of how SMS and email stack up when driving customer action:

With a conversion rate of 29%, SMS campaigns are more effective at encouraging immediate engagement, which can lead to stronger customer retention.

Cost vs Results

When evaluating ROI, it’s important to consider both costs and the long-term impact of retention:

Platform Investment:

• Email platforms generally have lower bulk messaging costs, ranging from $0.0001 to $0.0005 per email.

• SMS services are pricier, costing around $0.01 to $0.05 per message.

• Both require automation tools to maximize efficiency.

Resource Requirements:

• Email campaigns often need more design and content creation, while SMS relies on short, concise messages.

• Both channels benefit from personalization and audience segmentation.

Interestingly, 64% of consumers prefer SMS for delivery confirmations, showing how channel preference can influence customer satisfaction and loyalty.

For retention campaigns, SMS often delivers better ROI because of higher engagement, despite its higher upfront costs. However, the best results often come from using both channels together, playing to each one's strengths while balancing their limitations.

Email Marketing Results

Email marketing offers a strong return on investment, with an average of $36 earned for every dollar spent. For e-commerce, this figure can go up to $45, making it a cost-effective option for businesses.

Why Email Marketing Works

When used well, email can build lasting customer relationships while working alongside quicker communication tools like SMS.

With 88% of consumers checking their email daily, it’s a dependable way to maintain communication. Plus, its low cost per message makes it easy to scale for retention campaigns.

Challenges of Email Marketing

Even with its advantages, email marketing isn’t without its hurdles when it comes to keeping customers engaged:

Inbox Overload: Open rates average around 32.55%, though some industries see rates above 47%. Competing for attention in crowded inboxes is tough.

Deliverability Problems: Spam filters and promotional tabs can block emails from reaching the main inbox, reducing their impact.

Subscriber Burnout: While 79% of millennials prefer brand communication via email, overloading them with messages can lead to disengagement. Striking the right balance in frequency and content is key.

Tips for Better Email Retention

To get the most out of email marketing for retention, try these strategies:

• Personalized Content: Use customer data to send messages that feel relevant and tailored.

• Mobile-Friendly Designs: Over half of emails are opened on mobile. Make sure your emails are easy to read with larger fonts, clear calls-to-action (CTAs), and optimized images.

• Automated Workflows: Set up automated emails for actions like welcoming new subscribers, following up after purchases, re-engaging inactive users, and sharing loyalty updates.

Track metrics like open rates, click-through rates, and conversions regularly. Use A/B testing to refine subject lines and content for better results.

While email is perfect for detailed and personalized communication, SMS stands out for its ability to deliver instant engagement and responses. Both can complement each other in a retention strategy.

SMS Marketing Results

SMS marketing has become a highly effective approach for keeping customers engaged, thanks to its impressive performance metrics.

SMS Marketing Advantages

SMS marketing stands out with its 98% open rate and 45% response rate - numbers that far surpass email. Its quick delivery and short format make it perfect for time-sensitive updates, flash sales, and real-time communication. Here's how SMS compares to email:

Challenges of SMS Marketing

While SMS marketing delivers strong results, it does come with a few limitations:

• Character Restrictions: The 160-character limit means messages must be concise. Additionally, compliance with privacy regulations like TCPA requires managing opt-ins carefully to avoid legal issues.

• Higher Costs: SMS campaigns can be more expensive per message compared to other channels. However, the higher engagement rates often make the investment worthwhile.

Tips to Boost SMS Retention

To get the most out of SMS marketing, consider these strategies:

• Send messages during optimal hours, typically between 10 AM and 8 PM.

• Use automation for tasks like post-purchase follow-ups, cart abandonment reminders, and loyalty program updates.

• Keep messages short and include clear calls-to-action (CTAs) to encourage immediate responses.

SMS works best when paired with email. While SMS offers immediacy and high engagement, email provides more room for in-depth communication. Together, they create a strong foundation for customer retention campaigns.

Combining Email and SMS

Pairing email with SMS takes advantage of each channel’s strengths to create a stronger retention strategy. When used thoughtfully, these two channels work together to provide a more engaging customer experience.

How They Work Together

The magic happens when these channels are coordinated effectively. Here’s a quick breakdown:

By aligning the timing and purpose of each channel, businesses can guide customers through a smooth journey that boosts retention.

Better Results with Multi-Channel Strategies

When email and SMS are combined, retention metrics often see a noticeable improvement. For example, sending an SMS for cart abandonment followed by a detailed email can increase recovery rates by 25-40%. Similarly, customer engagement grows when SMS is used for delivery updates, while email offers product tips and recommendations.

This approach works because it creates multiple touchpoints while ensuring each channel is used where it performs best. The result? Consistent engagement from the first purchase to long-term loyalty.

Real-World Example: A Beauty Brand’s Success

A beauty brand saw its cart recovery rate jump from 15% to 38% and improved retention by 56% within six months by combining SMS and email. Their strategy included:

• Smart timing between SMS and email

• Tailored product recommendations

• Instant SMS alerts for urgent updates

• Detailed product guides and follow-ups via email

This approach leveraged SMS’s 98% open rate alongside email’s ability to deliver rich, informative content, showcasing how these two channels can work together to drive impressive retention results.

The key to success lies in using each channel at the right time, creating a well-coordinated strategy that enhances the customer experience at every step.

Conclusion

Email and SMS marketing serve different purposes but work well together for customer retention. SMS excels in speed, boasting high open and response rates, while email allows for more detailed, personalized communication that nurtures relationships over time.

Here’s a quick comparison of when to use each:

Your choice between SMS and email should align with your business goals and customer expectations. Together, they cover both urgent communication and ongoing engagement.

To build a strong retention strategy, focus on:

• Understanding customer preferences and maintaining consistent messaging

• Using automation to send timely, relevant messages

• Regularly analyzing engagement metrics to improve results

Don’t overlook legal compliance, especially for SMS marketing, where opt-in rules are strict. Following regulations and leveraging the unique benefits of each channel will help you connect with your audience effectively.

Check out the FAQs below for more insights into these channels.

FAQs

What is the response rate for text messages vs email?

Text messages have a much higher response rate - 45% - compared to email, which stands at just 6%. This makes SMS an excellent choice for quick engagement.

Here’s how the two compare on key performance metrics:

The stronger performance of SMS can be explained by a few factors:

• Speed: People usually respond to SMS within minutes, whereas email responses can take hours or even days.

• High Visibility: About 98% of SMS messages are opened, compared to only 20% of emails.

• Ease of Use: A majority of consumers (64%) prefer receiving updates like delivery confirmations via SMS.

While SMS leads in immediate engagement, email still plays a valuable role in retention strategies. SMS is ideal for urgent updates, while email works better for in-depth content and relationship building.

For the best results, combine both channels. Use SMS for time-sensitive messages and email for detailed communication. Together, they create a well-rounded, multi-channel approach to keep your audience engaged.

Related posts

• How to Automate Email Marketing with AI: A Step-by-Step Guide

• 10 Signs Your Customer Retention Strategy Needs AI

• Solving Cart Abandonment: AI-Powered Recovery Strategies

• 6 Best Practices for AI-Driven Email Personalization